Anthropic’s IPO, the biggest in history, has had its first day of trading, raising about $81 billion at $83 a share and closing just over $97, about 17% higher, after jumping as much as 34% at the open. It debuted into a weak market, with U.S. indexes near seven-month lows. On Capital Markets: Wall Street to MENA, host Raghda Ibraheem asks Paul Howard, senior director at Wincent, what the debut says about investor appetite for AI.
Paul Howard says the market shows a ferocious appetite for AI and a flight to quality, and sees the debut as a positive signal after two tumultuous weeks for tech. He highlights how venues like Hyperliquid traded perpetuals on the shares before the IPO, which he says created a visible gray market and a new price discovery mechanism. With a small float, he expects heavy volatility, and says the latest Hyperliquid prices he saw were around $90 on day two.
On what comes next, Paul Howard believes the listing lifts the AI sector in the short term and brings capital in over the longer term as the shares enter indices, though rumored listings such as OpenAI’s could disperse some of it. He says the valuation is justified in some investors’ minds and not others, citing lockups, new competitors, China’s push into AI and open-source models, and while he is not a sector analyst, he compares the six and 12 month lockups to the ICO boom in crypto, saying investors should watch when new supply hits the market.
Get the latest news and updates on FINTECH.TV
Raghda Ibraheem: The biggest IPO in history has had its first day on the market. Anthropic raised about $81 billion at $83 a share, then closed its first day of trading just over $97, about 17% higher after jumping as much as 34% at the open. But it debuted into a weak market with U.S. indexes near seven-month lows. So what does this debut tell us about investor appetite for AI?
Joining me is Paul Howard. He’s senior director at Wincent. Paul, welcome to Capital Markets. Anthropic raised about $81 billion in the largest IPO on record, and shares closed about 17% above the IPO price. What does that tell us about the market’s appetite for AI?
Paul Howard: Yeah, it comes at an exciting time as well, obviously with the Nvidia news and the selloff that we’ve seen over the last fortnight. I think the message from the market here is that it’s still a big market for people. There’s a ferocious appetite for AI. There’s obviously a flight to quality, if we want to call it that.
People are looking at which of these guys are going to be the winner and an opportunity to get in here. Both pre-market and post-market, the trading yesterday has really excited investors. So I would like to think that this is a very positive signal for the market after two weeks of what’s been quite a tumultuous time for tech.
Raghda Ibraheem: Yeah, definitely. But I want to also get the picture from you, Paul. Nasdaq futures drop now as Anthropic falls just one day after the debut. How do we see the picture now?
Paul Howard: Well, the interesting thing for me [unclear: “in the team”] is what happens with the shares that are tokenized. You can see that some of the venues, like Hyperliquid and others, are trading these perpetuals pre-market and pre-IPO, which has created a dual market, or at least a visible gray market for shares, that didn’t really exist in the past.
So that is a new price discovery mechanism, and it’s a really interesting place. Obviously, there’s a ton of volatility on the listing date here, and I think what people are trying to do is figure out where that price discovery is, where exactly this thing should be priced. And whilst we’re all very much observing what happens in the lit markets, having access to trade this pre-market or indeed off-market, be it Hyperliquid or other venues, is a new concept for us and a really exciting one for the crypto industry.
Raghda Ibraheem: Now, this is the first day of listing. As we said, we’re seeing chip stocks decline today as well. What does this day actually look like, and what happens to liquidity and volatility in the markets?
Paul Howard: Yeah, I mean, the actual float in this case is relatively small, so we expect a lot of volatility on day one. As you come into an event like this on any trading desk, whether that’s a big Wall Street firm or a crypto desk that’s trading these names, you’ve got to think about preparation. So making sure that you have the liquidity in place, and you’ve got to make sure that you’re pricing this stuff with all the information that you can.
Because there’s such a tiny amount of float going into the market relative to the size, the volatility is going to be pulled one way or the other. What we’re seeing, I think, the latest prices I saw on Hyperliquid were that this thing is trading around $90 now. There’s obviously been a lot of movement on day one.
Day two, yeah, I think the vibe is that people are still trying to price this thing. And with many pricing sources now coming from nontraditional exchanges, this is a big opportunity for everybody who wants to get involved with these tech names.
Raghda Ibraheem: Yeah. Now, the debut came while U.S. indexes were near seven-month lows. Does a listing like this lift the whole AI sector, or does it pull money into a single name?
Paul Howard: A bit of both, I would imagine, and I think that’s probably going to change over time. What we’ll see with a big listing, like with Aramco and other names, is that these will then form part of the indices. So when those rebalance in the coming weeks and months, I would expect that whole sector continues to be quite buoyant.
So I would say it probably lifts the sector short term, but more importantly, brings capital into the segment over the longer term. Now, whether you get new listings coming up in the next six months, obviously there are rumors around OpenAI and others listing that could disperse some of this capital. We’ll wait and see. But again, you’ve got this really interesting narrative where having multiple venues to trade is becoming the new norm. And that’s a really interesting evolution of digital assets and the confluence with TradFi.
Raghda Ibraheem: Now, at the IPO price, the company was valued at about $1.5 trillion after the first day. Is that price justified, or is the market pricing in perfection here?
Paul Howard: Yeah, I think in a market like this, it’s justified in some people’s heads, not others. That’s the investors’ decision here. I think what people are trying to price is the uncertainty. You’ve got things to consider, such as lockups. You’ve got things to consider, such as new competitors coming onto the market. There’s obviously a big push from China into this AI space. There are also open-source models coming online.
So in terms of justifying, certainly short term, this seems to be a price that people are putting on the company. I’m not an analyst of the sector by any imagination, but I think what we’ll see here is that there are a lot of rivals coming into the space. And if we’re thinking about how you could execute against a potential backdrop of regulatory or otherwise changes to this environment, and all of the risks that may come in the next couple of years with AI, people are making some decisions here that, luckily, the market can support and give liquidity for people to come in and out quite quickly.
Raghda Ibraheem: Okay. Speaking of decisions, I want to get your thoughts on [unclear: “this poll here”]. A lot of ordinary investors will want in, of course, and we’re seeing this movement anyway. After this big first day, and in the days leading up to it, how should they approach a stock like this?
Paul Howard: In my head, I look at this as quite similar to how some of these crypto ICOs happened many years ago, when there was the ICO boom in crypto. You had these lockups that would keep investors and others kind of on the sidelines. And we see it with Anthropic and other deals, where you’ve got six-month, 12-month-plus lockups.
So I think playing that game, where the supply is coming onto the market, is going to be critical for folks. Knowing that the supply will increase on a certain date can give you certainty around how you want to price that. And then it becomes a race with the demand side: are they hitting their revenue targets? Are they hitting earnings targets? What are those windows like? And so you’re going to get patches of volatility, which I think, if people are trading this and jumping in and out of this thing intraday, it’s going to be a really interesting market for people to be aware of and to have the opportunity to trade. So yeah, looking at those signals is interesting.
Raghda Ibraheem: We’re going to keep an eye on that. Thank you so much, Paul, for being with us on the show today.
Paul Howard: Thank you.
