Raghda Ibraheem: A blockbuster AI listing is set to hit the Nasdaq, with Anthropic expected to begin trading under the ticker ANT. Reports say orders topped $500 billion, roughly eight times the shares on offer, but the AI trade is also under strain. Nvidia beat estimates this week, yet the Nasdaq slipped as well. And of course, we have this.
This is the peak of the AI boom. Or is it also the start of a new phase? So, joining me from London now is Adam Morgan McCarthy. He’s the head of research at LO:TECH, and we’re going to talk all about it. So, Adam, welcome to the show. Adam, let’s talk about Anthropic, set to debut at the Nasdaq today. The futures, at least, jumped 2%, with reported orders as well for Anthropic.
Let’s talk about the demand here. What does demand like that... Tell us about where investors want to put their money at.
Adam Morgan McCarthy: Yeah, thanks so much for having me. It’s a big day for markets. I think it’s a good time to be chatting about this topic. I think, you know, look, the AI trade, as you talked about there, has come under strain a little bit this year. In part, that’s been kind of multifaceted, though. It’s not just been broad AI. It’s been maybe memory stocks in Korea. At other times, you’ve seen data center, mining stocks in the US come under pressure after the midterm elections a couple of weeks ago. But in terms of demand for this product, I think it’s a little bit different, and in a way separated from those other issues that we’ve seen.
You know, I was talking to someone this week and they said, “I use Claude every day. I’ve got to have a bit of exposure to that.” So I think there’s a lot of demand that’s going to come in that sense. You know, it’s the sort of old Warren Buffett adage: if you use and consume something, you should try and own a bit of that stock.
I think there’s going to be a lot of people out there that want to have exposure to this. They want to have, you know, potential exposure to the upside of Anthropic, which might not be in the next, you know, week, six weeks or six months. But I think it’s a long-term play, right? I think we all agree that AI is here to stay in some form or another. There might be a shakeout in the next while, but owning ANT seems like only a bit of the future. And I think that that’s a really, really nice appeal to people.
Raghda Ibraheem: Now, the company is reportedly valued at around $1.5 trillion, below the $2 trillion that was once talked about. Does that look like a sensible price for an AI company, or is it still demanding?
Adam Morgan McCarthy: I think, you know, it’s difficult to say what’s sensible in AI, right? SpaceX went live in June, I think it was in May. And that was, you know, trillions as well. It immediately shook out a bit, and it’s traded lower since. They obviously had a small float on launch. I don’t know what to say about, you know, sensibility or pricing.
I’m not doing a sort of a DCF here on this thing. I’m not an investment banker. But I think purely from a market-making point of view, if you’re looking at what the fair price for this is right now, and if you look at what’s indicative on Hyperliquid, on places like trade.xyz and Entropy, they’re pricing this thing around $105. Or, you know, I think Entropy is pricing it near $1.8 trillion implied valuation, based on what that perpetual future is trading at. So I think it priced at $83 last night. They’re seeing a huge upside, which is showing the demand. I think if you’re looking at purely market forces in terms of pricing, then it seems like a fair price from that point of view.
I’m not willing to speak on the underlying financials, [unclear: “had this, you know, just circling circling finance”]. But I think it seems like a fair price for where we’re at in the market right now with AI and the AI trade, for sure.
Raghda Ibraheem: Now, speaking of AI in general, Nvidia reported revenue of more than $115 billion and guided higher. Yet AI stocks have been swinging, like we were saying, swinging sharply. Now, are investors right to worry about whether all this AI spending will pay off afterwards? What do you think, Adam?
Adam Morgan McCarthy: I think there’s a right to be a little bit afraid and a little bit cautious right now. You know, I think we’re seeing [unclear: “a lot of pop into the market”]. About 12 months ago, there were people saying, you know, I think some of these CEOs, of Anthropic, like Dario Amodei and stuff, were coming and saying, you know, white-collar jobs are going to be gone and there’s not going to be, sort of, you know, new grads. There won’t be new grads getting jobs in two years. I think that was a very good marketing. It was very good shock value. But people rolled back from that. And I think right now we’re [unclear: “probably a simple replace the market”] where there’s been a lot of spending, there’s a lot of work on the data center build-out and those sorts of things, and it’s kind of made people hesitant, like, okay, there’s a lot of overpromising in this market, which is like any new, nascent market, but where is it really going to shake out?
And people are sort of just standing back. So I guess some of that might be a little less liquidity at times in pockets of the market. It’s not normal to see, you know, multi-billion-dollar or trillion-dollar companies trade down 10%. I think we can all agree on that. So when that’s happening, you’ve probably got, you know, people in the market who are stepping back a bit, and that’s why you’re seeing a lot of the kind of, you know, volatility that we’re seeing there.
People aren’t sure where this is going next. There are obviously the macro factors we talked about before. You’re talking about the jobs figures and data out of the US. That’s also putting a strain on things, the ability to borrow and to kind of fund this build-out over the next few years. There’s a lot of unknowns right now.
I think the Anthropic IPO today would be great. The Nvidia earnings are great to see. They’ve been posting record earnings for a while. I don’t think that has as much play as it used to. So I think what we really need to see is the broader economy, in those areas where the AI will be useful, where it will fit in, and what, you know, what will justify that spending. So I think that’s why we’re seeing a little bit of a kind of, you know, froth in the market right now.
Raghda Ibraheem: Yeah. And speaking of uncertainty that we’re seeing at the moment, the wariness maybe as well. Now, Nvidia also reported its first results since Jensen Huang resigned. How much does leadership matter for investors in a company that size?
Adam Morgan McCarthy: I think it’s huge, right? Like, you know, we look at, sort of, the mobile phone kind of breakout in the late noughties, I guess it was, someone like Steve Jobs, people like this. You look at Facebook, Zuckerberg. You look at those kind of charismatic leaders that drive firms on, especially in something like this, where there might not be a product-market fit for everything they’re building. They’re throwing a lot of things at the wall and seeing what fits. You need a charismatic leader sometimes, and someone that can kind of lead that and lead that push.
Especially with something like chips. And, you know, what Nvidia do, it’s only very few people understand how they do that and what they do. The multitude of those investors and people who are putting that stuff and allocating to their Roth IRAs or whatever, [unclear: “they’re for one case”], they don’t understand that business, but they understand someone like Jensen Huang, who seems like a serious person and a solid leader.
So he was very important to that Nvidia push, undoubtedly. I think, you know, these earnings were obviously heavily influenced by his reign while he was there. So we’ll see in February, I guess, when we get the next kind of set of earnings out of here, February, March, how that new leadership has gone, and that things might shake out a bit more then.
I think the messaging was good this week. They had obviously very nice earnings to report on, which helped cushion that. But it’s definitely going to be something that’s going to play out and be a headline for a time to come. I think we saw in prediction markets people betting a 12% chance that Huang will be back before the end of the year. I don’t know if it’s going to be quite like Sam Altman. Yeah, I’ve seen that position, but yeah, it’s definitely a lot, I think, happening now with Nvidia, and we’re going to keep an eye on that.
Raghda Ibraheem: And a lot has been changing as well. So thank you so much, Adam, for being with us on the show tonight. Today.
Adam Morgan McCarthy: Thank you. Thanks so much for having me.