Kristin Myers: Artificial intelligence is swallowing venture capital. AI startups took 64% of all global venture dollars last quarter, and that’s according to Crunchbase. But for most founders, the hardest money to raise isn’t the first check. It’s the money that gets them from seed to Series A. Now, my guest has sat on both sides of that table.
He built his first online business at the age of 16, and today he runs Pilotly, an AI market research platform used by both Amazon and Netflix. He also co-founded Black Operator Ventures, a $20 million seed fund that just led a $4 million round for a healthcare startup called MedHaul. But first, let’s take a look at the company.
The road from an idea to the opening bell starts right now.
[Package]: Every investor wants to find the next billion-dollar startup. But what if the best person to spot one is someone who’s already built a business himself? Meet James Norman. He’s the CEO of Pilotly, an AI-powered market research platform used by companies like Amazon and Netflix. And now he’s on the other side of the pitch table as co-founder and managing partner of Black Operator Ventures.
Norman is backing early-stage startups with a focus on companies built around artificial intelligence. One recent bet, MedHaul, a startup tackling transportation barriers to healthcare, with Black Ops leading its funding round. But here’s the challenge with AI startups launching every day. How do you separate the next industry leader from just another big promise? And can Norman turn his experience as a founder into a winning investment strategy? From Startup to Stock Exchange, Black Ops VC co-founder James Norman is next.
Kristin Myers: Joining us now here at the desk is James Norman, co-founder and managing partner of Black Operator Ventures. James, thank you so much for joining us today. So, we were just talking about this while everyone was watching the package. You built your first online business at the age of 16, which is pretty incredible, and that was an aftermarket auto parts site back home in Michigan. How did you go from doing that to where you are now, running a venture fund?
James Norman: Man, that’s a lot of things. But, you know, even before I was doing stuff online, I had a video game business. I was selling video game tips and renting games. I’ve always been an entrepreneur. It was just the serendipitous thing of the automotive industry. It was like, there’s a lot of pieces of the puzzle. There’s manufacturing, there’s the dealer network, there’s the design studio. And I was participating across all those as the years passed. But when I left University of Michigan, I was building cars for Honda, Mazda, Ford. I moved to LA. And so once I brought all those cars to LA, the people who were in LA were like, “Who’s this guy with all the cars?” So then I got tied into the whole, like, Fast and Furious franchise. And that gave me exposure to the Hollywood world. And when the kind of financial... actually, the Fast and Furious franchise.
Kristin Myers: Oh, okay. I thought you were saying that as a [unclear: “fun addict”].
James Norman: Yeah. I mean, because a lot of people in those movies were real people who were really street racing. And so, like, I met those people through the networks I had as a person who really was building cars. And so then when they were doing the next movies, it was like, “Well, he’s got to be there,” and we started building the cars and being a part of the thing. But that gave me exposure to how Hollywood works. I saw this team of people coming together for a common cause, only to execute that thing and then disperse to the next stage. I was like, this is a complicated system. This is kind of like manufacturing a car. Like, people are coming and putting the pieces together. Thing comes out, gets distributed. When the financial crisis hit, that business obviously started waning, right? But I was so entangled in the Hollywood world. Something in my mind said, people aren’t going to have cable TV in 20 years. Like, why am I even paying for this? It’s not giving me what I want. It’s expensive. So I ended up building one of the first electronic programming guides to stream all video online to one place. And that journey led me through my first real tech startup experience, right? That was inspired by one of my friends who started Dropbox. He came from MIT. He raised money at Y Combinator. He did all these things, and I was like, I want to go do that too. So I pursued that journey, and that, over time, you know, brought me over to where I am now.
But there were many pieces of the puzzle, and the key pieces of the puzzle were exposure to that. This was a possibility. The second piece was, like, you know, there’s a house called [unclear: “Nummi”] that brought me to Silicon Valley, which is where a lot of people were there who, you know now. And that house gave me the ability to be in the space, was some of the best. It’s how I met Mitch Kapor, how I [unclear: “might have been”] Horowitz, etc. And then once you got familiar with the landscape, the language and the people, now you can start trying to play the game. Obviously, there’s more barriers for me to play that game than other people. Which then led me to other things. Here we are doing the, you know...
Kristin Myers: Okay, so let’s talk about where you are now, because you’re the CEO of Pilotly, which is really interesting because it lets studios and brands test shows and ads with real audiences before they’re even launched or released. So, how does that work? How does AI change that?
James Norman: Well, when we started, it was like a la carte TV service. It didn’t get funded. We pivoted it to become Pilotly by making it interactive and collecting data. Hulu and, like, Netflix and stuff like that, they don’t give data back to the studios. So I was like, we can give you data. They said, “Well, we get data in focus groups in Orlando and Vegas and Burbank.” I was like, that’s cool. What happens in five years when you have global content contracts? You’re not going to catch someone in a mall in Nigeria to give them a test. So I was like, we need to do this online. So that’s where Pilotly came from. It was an evolution of what had traditionally been the in-person market research. But with AI, the thing changes, right? We happen to have been doing this for long enough. We have ten years of data around how people respond to creative stimulus, right? Like Anthropic, like a Claude or a GPT, can’t watch TV, right? We have watched TV for ten years. So that data allows us to actually simulate what it’s like for different personas, for different places in the world, to consume creative content and respond to it.
Kristin Myers: So, using the data that you already have, that you’ve been amassing for the past decade, you were able to train an AI model to then react the way that exactly a person would in that space. Right? React and model.
James Norman: Right. Because, like, in doing that now, the research that you do, if you do it with humans, it doesn’t become, like, a one-off piece of information. It becomes part of your repository where you’re training your own proprietary model that can then talk to our model, which has all this historical context. Right? So now, if you ran that study, you ran 20 of them, you might be doing the next one and say, “Oh, remember ten studies ago where you learned this? I think that applies here.” And that saves the human cycles that they don’t need to go through. The humans are in charge of the story. The humans are in charge of intuition, domain expertise, you know, where the human knows more than the model. That’s where the human needs to be. So, yeah.
Kristin Myers: So, I want to go back to something that you said a moment ago about how it was harder for you, right, when you were raising money than it is for some other folks. I’m going to guess, it’s not too hard to guess, that part of the reason is because you are a person of color, because you are a Black man. So I want to talk about the Transparent Collective, which you co-founded before Black Ops, which was to help overlooked founders get funded. Talk to me about what you learned about where venture money goes and really where it doesn’t go.
James Norman: Yeah, I mean, end of the day, venture money is going into extraordinary people who are looking to do something that is extraordinary at scale. And typically you’re identifying people that you want to work with over a long period of time, and you look for proof points in the product. But this is really a people game in a way that most you can’t explain, because they had to spend the time to be self-aware enough about how the people part works. As I’ve dove into this, I’ve become more of a, I don’t know, like, I’m a student of human personality and thought process and things like that. Like, the reality is, ten, 15 years ago, media shapes how we look at people, even how we look at ourselves. And so you don’t tend to think that someone who looks like me doing this thing, one, is possible, but two, is extraordinary. Or the thing I’m saying is extraordinary. So you’re already operating from a deficit. So your storytelling has to be tremendous, right? Right. Our community thinks about business as results, outcomes, hard work, you know, diligence. Those are things that exist. There’s also the story around it that makes everybody believe.
Your job as a tech founder is to create believers. You have to create believers in your employees, believers in your customers, believers in these investors. And it requires craft. And so I think, like, while I don’t consider Silicon Valley of some intentional bias, everybody has the bias of what they think is super intelligent, what’s super smart, and what’s a great opportunity. And the only way to shift that bias is through, like, great storytelling and results. So that’s why we built Transparent Collective. The basis of it at first is, like, how do I put you in the network? How do you tell the story that makes everybody a believer? Because once everybody’s a believer, the money will come.
Kristin Myers: So let’s talk about Black Ops. You founded that in 2021 along with Sean Green. You closed your $20 million first fund. So, going from Transparent Collective into Black Ops, what were you trying... was there a gap that you were trying to fill, or what were you trying to do with Black Ops that you weren’t able to do, perhaps?
James Norman: I mean, I was just doing Transparent Collective. The things were fine, and Pilotly was scaling crazy because of the pandemic. You couldn’t test things in person anymore, so now Pilotly was the thing. But my partner Sean called me because he had a bunch of conversations. He was talking with Fred Wilson here at USV in New York, and Fred was like, “You guys know where the best [unclear: “electronics”] are? You know the best. You should have a fund. Why don’t you invest in these kind of founders?” And Sean calls: “We’ve got to invest in the founders later.” No, we’re going to start a fund. “Don’t worry. We’ll sell our companies. We’ll start a fund.” I was like, he’s like, “No, we’ve got to do it right now.” I was like, well, let me think about it. So I thought about it for, like, an evening, and I was like, okay, for a long time, I do want to do this. It’s a pandemic, so we can actually do this from our living room. And I do believe we’ll be uniquely equipped, being active entrepreneurs serving entrepreneurs. I think that’s a unique edge that I don’t see in other funds. So I was like, let’s go do it. You know, it was always on the horizon. But when you find someone who has just the same amount of passion for it and the timing is right, just crazy enough to just go after what’s put right in front of you.
Kristin Myers: Now, you guys have narrowed your focus to AI-native companies. What does AI-native, you know, really mean?
James Norman: That’s a good question, right? What does that mean? Because what’s the difference between that and just using something that’s just built off of Claude or off of... Exactly. So it’s like, you know, if you [unclear: “sense your work”] every day and you’re like, I can find some files using AI, I find files easier. Oh, I can answer this quick question, or I can pull in a bunch of articles, or I can synthesize this Excel sheet. That’s cool. That’s use of AI in your workflows. AI-native, Pilotly, is like, we have a central intelligence system that’s built. So there’s a product lobe of the brain. There’s an HR lobe of the brain, there’s an executive lobe, there’s lobes for every portion of the business. And those lobes are trained by people who’ve been doing this work for years. Right? And then they evolve through the conversations and activities that we have as a company. So it’s always listening on every phone call, whether it’s a sales call or an internal call. And that means when I go to, like, shape a new deck or I go to, like, tell a new story around a product, there’s so much context from the conversations I wasn’t in that it could help me shape that better than it would be possible if it didn’t exist. And, like, that’s being AI-native, where you’re actually, like, supercharging your intelligence in ways that weren’t possible pre-AI, not just, like, doing something faster, but doing something that wasn’t possible because I wasn’t in these 20 conversations. Right? Right. So I went to go work with Sony about synthetic audience. The ten conversations my research team and my engineering team had without me, I didn’t need to go ask them about. Right? And that’s, like, operating AI-native.
Kristin Myers: Venture capital is pouring into artificial intelligence at a record pace. Global startup funding hit $679 billion in the first nine months of this year. That’s the highest nine-month total on record, according to Crunchbase. Now, the first quarter set the pace: $300 billion in venture funding, with about 80% of it going to AI companies. But in the third quarter, AI startups raised $102 billion, and that’s 64% of all venture money that’s been invested worldwide. And a record 27 companies raised rounds of $1 billion or more in that quarter alone. So the money is flowing. The question for early-stage investors is how much of it ever reaches the smallest startups.
We’re back now with James Norman, co-founder and managing partner of Black Operator Ventures. So, you just heard those record numbers: AI startups taking 64% of all venture dollars last quarter, 27 companies raising $1 billion or more, so becoming unicorns just like that. How does a $20 million, you know, seed fund compete in a market that’s large?
James Norman: These are good questions. So, you know, first thing is, like, you’ve got to be in the Mecca, right? So you say 60% of the capital, 68% of the money was in the Bay. So, like, it’s a lot of money moving in the Bay. And that is where the frontier is. That’s where the rails that the railroad cars will travel on are being built in this modern era. So being in that space is important. I’ve been in that space for a long time, long before many people were trying to participate. But also, Transparent Collective has brought me across the country, touching the in-between, because 78% of GDP, you know, gross, gross national product, is happening between the coasts. And so my network is both strong in the Valley but is bespoke between the coasts. We have [unclear: “Ires”] and network nodes in every major city that would participate in between: Memphis, Detroit, New Orleans, Tulsa, etc. So that gives me, like, really close proximity to what I think is important now, which is people building next to a problem. It’s always been important, but now it’s imperative, because building costs zero. And so what could be expensive? Being close to the problem. So the next wave of AI that’s going to happen is that money starts to shift out of the Bay. It’s going to be between the coasts.
Kristin Myers: Say more about that. What does that necessarily mean, being next to the problem?
James Norman: So, like, imagine someone like [unclear: “a mentor”] where, you know, we had led that round. She’s raised $4.1 million. She experienced her grandmother not being able to get transportation to care for her diabetes. She [unclear: “didn’t work that”] St. Jude as a result of that experience and saw logistics fail. She then built an AI-driven logistics platform to ensure that patients with life-threatening disease can get to their daily, you know, treatments on a regular basis at a 94% delivery rate, which is two times what it is without her software. She lived that problem, was close to it, worked in it, knows how to solve it, knows how to monetize it.
Kristin Myers: Okay, so speaking about MedHaul, they say about 60% of the rides booked on this platform are for cancer care. So how big is the transportation problem in healthcare? You just sort of touched on it, but say a little bit more about that. And where does the AI come in? Because, again, you’re doing all AI-native companies. Where is the AI piece?
James Norman: So her company is one of those that comes kind of pre-generative AI. So she’s made a transformation to begin leveraging AI in a more native way. But for her, it’s more about the decision-making of what transportation is available for what person and getting more fidelity around where exactly the vehicle needs to be to get that person. Because the person who’s walking with a walker, who the car is going to wait for five minutes, who’s around the block and has the wrong vehicle, is not going to make it to the treatment. Right? So it’s about the decision-making around who’s where, you know, this person and with what, to get them to the right place on time, and then having some intelligence around the follow-up that’s required to ensure that the person is taking the right measures to be prepared and signed up for the things that need to be signed up for to get to the actual hospital. So, like, that’s how she’s doing it. And, like, from an overall business standpoint, I think the data she’s collecting around the quality of care and the better outcomes will help her in terms of a value-based business solution, where she’s able to capture more value from insurance payers and whatnot, because she is helping reduce the cost of insurance being spent on people who are having worse outcomes because they don’t make it too... by creating a more efficient logistics to help them get to their appointments.
Kristin Myers: Okay. Let’s talk about you. When you meet a founder, a founder walks in to pitch you, what are you looking for? What are the instant red flags, or things where you say, “Absolutely not, I’m not touching this,” beyond it not being perhaps AI-native, since that is your focus?
James Norman: Oh, it was funny. My instant red flag, like, hearkens back to how I was, like, 15 years ago. You’re, like, in the pitch. You’re talking, everything goes smooth. They’re pretty impressed. But they have questions, because what you said was kind of complicated. They start asking the questions and you start just, like, firing back on them, firing it back like, “Okay, yeah, no, this is exactly how it works.” You’re trying to convince them that the thing you just told them is right, as opposed to explaining the things you just told them in a way that makes more sense to them. And you’re doing it in a way that is being too much of a smooth talker. It sounds like we’re talking to be cool, but, like, doing it in a way where it feels like you are just answering the question. You’re answering a question in a way that feels like it’s defensive and you’re trying to convince me, as opposed to expanding my world to better understand the thing I’m doing. So, like, that’s a red flag. It doesn’t mean we can’t figure out a way through it. That’s a way of Transparent Collective. Sometimes we can take red flags and turn them into green flags by saying, “Hey, you should try Transparent Collective and build that person up.”
What we look for is people who are, one again, like, high, high, high knowledge around the problem, right? People who are super resilient. So we have to find life experiences of resilience. People are convicted they can win at scale, you know. Do you believe you can go do this at scale? Not just build a great company. Can you do this in a way that no one else can? Are you the person to do this? And coachability is super important. So you have to have a point of view. You have to be, you know, pretty kind of stubborn around your point of view, because you believe you’re going to do it the best, but you’re able to take in information and your slope to information adoption is very quick. So you’re able to, like, recalibrate very quickly: this is good information, I now need to put it to work, so I can change the way I’m either managing and executing, building. That quick change is the difference between having a company that fails and doesn’t fail further, you know?
Kristin Myers: Yeah, exactly. Is there a delusion factor for you that has to exist in founders? Because I ask every person who is a VC this question, the level to which they’re looking for a founder who’s a little bit, you can’t, almost insanely passionate about what they’re doing.
James Norman: It’s just the thing, like, again, you can be that insanely passionate, but be able to take in real-life information and, like, calibrate your delusion. That’s important. But delusion is a requirement, which has also been why we’ve had Transparent Collective, to build people up over time, because that’s not inherent in subpopulations of people. You want to build a multi-billion-dollar company. There’s delusion that comes along with that, because you cannot master your way and napkin-math your way to $1 billion with anything that doesn’t exist yet. Right? That’s delusion. Right? And that’s just part of the game.
Kristin Myers: So every VC is different. Some just hand over the check. What does Black Ops do beyond the check that you hand over to the founder?
James Norman: First things first. Whoever we’re invested in, I lived your life in my previous lifetime. Between me and Sean, we’ve lived that life. So no matter what you think you’re going through, like, “Oh my God, no one’s ever seen this before,” I’m like, let me tell you the exact time I experienced that before and how we got through that. So first things first is, like, founder-to-founder empathy, direction and help. The next thing is network, right? The people who are original LPs, these people founded Dropbox, Slack, Twitch, NerdWallet, Andreessen Horowitz, Union Square Ventures, Foundry. Like, these are household names in the industry we’re in. So our network is pretty vast, and our ability to help you is pretty strong. And that shows in 83% of the seed rounds that we’ve led have been oversubscribed, which is pretty bespoke based on who we invest in typically.
Kristin Myers: Do you think that having been a founder yourself, that that also gives you an edge as an investor?
James Norman: Yeah, it’s more of an edge, right? Because imagine the whole market, just the whole world has changed. Most of the world doesn’t really know it. They’re just, like, typing in things to find food in AI. The world has changed. We know it because we transformed ten-year-old companies and the AI-native companies, and the market is completely shifted around the reception of the price that we’ve been delivering for years. So through that, that changes the lens of how we invest. Like, right now, we had a company we had to do an extension in last year that we’re going to do a seed in Q1, but there should have been a seed last year, but the market didn’t know what’s going on. The market said, “Well, where’s the one product the person sells? Repeat sells.” I’m like, that’s not the world. This is one problem. I can have repeat 15 solutions with the same engineering team and deliver across all my customer needs. I don’t need more money to do that. But the world didn’t understand that that’s a different way of doing business. But we knew that because we had been doing it ourselves. Right? Right. Another way to think about it is when we’re thinking about how we even run our firm, our firm is AI-native, so we’re not just, like, everyone else is using different connectors in Claude or whatever. We have our own infrastructure and central intelligence, you know, we’re continuing to develop as well, which I learned from doing it at my company. So the things we learn at our companies, we’re able to double down on within the fund, and vice versa. The things we learn in helping founders every day go back into our company. So everybody’s winning.
Kristin Myers: So talk to me about where you think the next business opportunities are going to come from, because AI has made it easier, cheaper than ever before to build something. You’ve said it doesn’t make it necessarily any cheaper to scale. I’m curious to know where you think the next sort of breakout or big business is going to be.
James Norman: I mean, there’s so many. It’s like that’s like saying, like, well, if someone just built, like, railroad tracks, now we have trains, where you want to take stuff, you can take it anywhere. Right? But, like, right now, like, high-level stats is, like, 1 in 10 logistics companies are using AI appropriately. And, like, AI-native, 1 in 5 manufacturing companies are using AI appropriately. Like, this stuff in between, in between the coasts, where people really have their proximity. You know, physical AI, that’s the next wave. Like, we have [unclear: “the mile”]. Now, we’ve had several of those founders here yesterday. We actually talked to a founder who’s building autonomous railway cars. Exactly. Like, all these AI, all these things are possible. And if I never got past Fable 5.2 on Anthropic, I think I’d be straight for, like, ten years. It’s so much intelligence available, right? It’s how you harness it.
So, like, there’s also the fact that as more of us use this and it becomes externally facing, that’s another surface for attack, too. We’re not talking enough about, like, security, identity theft, stuff like that. So in our company, like, we’ve been working with and helping Abliteration.ai. These guys know that an Anthropic model can’t attack another model. Its guardrails won’t allow it. So they built a guardrail-less model factory that they actually have inference for, that enterprises can use to red-team against their own systems. So as they put out a new surface into the world, they have appropriate models to attack it with intelligence that is that of a Fable 5.2. Like, the world needs that.
Kristin Myers: So, very quickly, like, ten, 20 seconds, I want to ask you if you have any companies inside of your portfolio, since this is all about the road to public markets, do you think could one day perhaps ring the bell right here at the New York Stock Exchange?
James Norman: I mean, I just talked about Abliteration.ai. I mean, you’re going to be working with them, and I think they’ll make it. But if you think about the people we already invested in, like EdVisorly, he’s made the AI that transfers credits between every college and university out there. I think that that is going to be a part of the future of education. There’s no need to have people missing semesters of school because their credits weren’t properly transposed. They’re growing so rapidly. They did a $13 million Series A in, like, six weeks earlier this year. You know, that’s the type of stuff we do at Black Ops.
Kristin Myers: All right. This is absolutely fascinating. Thank you so much. James Norman, co-founder and managing partner of Black Ops VC.