Raghda Ibraheem: The next generation of investors is learning from social media. A report in Khaleej Times says that nearly half of UAE Gen Z investors rely on online creators for their financial education. In March, the Dubai market fell 16.4%, its worst month since the pandemic, a real test for everyday investors. Retail investors are now a force in MENA markets, and what they know may decide how those markets behave. So joining me to unpack it all is Abdallah Harfoush, economist and founder of EcoLearn. Abdallah, welcome to Capital Markets.
Abdallah Harfoush: Hello. Thank you so much for hosting me.
Raghda Ibraheem: Of course. Thank you for being here with us. Now, retail investors are on the rise in MENA, from what we’re seeing now. What’s driving it?
Abdallah Harfoush: Actually, we are entering a new world. The world of information, and everything now became online. And information is available for everyone. So it isn’t anymore like something weird or something that people need to dig a lot into, Google to find. And now Gen Z and people, since they have their smartphone, their AI, they hear more about economics, they hear more about financial markets, they hear more about what’s happening in the world. So they feel like they are involved without really being involved. And then once they see these creators online and on the social media, and mentoring online events they are invited to, even in schools and universities that are implementing this more and more, so they feel, no, we have to be involved more. We have to know about this, and let’s try to invest, besides finding a job, or maybe building our own thing, whatever it is, for sure.
Raghda Ibraheem: It’s the new mindset, let’s say here. Now, nearly half of UAE Gen Z investors reportedly learn from online creators. And just like you mentioned, now from social media and content and stuff, is that good or bad?
Abdallah Harfoush: Actually, first of all, here in the UAE we congratulate, of course, the government always for keeping the environment safe for people and now implementing more rules for content creators when it comes to financial advice or something, so they can have more credibility at the end.
Yes, it is good as long as Gen Z, or as long as people who are getting this information on social media, do their due diligence and search to see if it’s good or not, not just perceive it and that’s it. It’s bad if they just take it from multiple sources without really checking on it, getting the right education about it, and then just implement without even knowing what they are implementing.
Raghda Ibraheem: Yeah, because we’re seeing now the rise of influencers or something like that, and people are listening to that for sure. Now, when markets fell sharply in March, what mistakes did new investors make?
Abdallah Harfoush: Panic. This is old. Even sometimes the old investors, who lose, not only the new but mainly new investors who join the market. They join expecting always to win. And when they make a wrong decision, if the market is falling simply like slowly, it’s good, they hold. But then when they see big drops or something happening fast, and in the news you see all the headlines are red, red, red, people panic and they start acting based on emotions rather than acting more with their mindset involved, being more patient or having a plan and being consistent on that plan.
Because it’s not always about the drops. If you are an investor, let’s say you don’t care about drops in the short term, you have to check the market. If the economy is going to crash, if something bad is going to happen for the longer term, then you can sell. But if it’s an instant thing that’s happening because of certain news, maybe a certain war or election or whatever example, then no, fundamentally it might recover. So you don’t have to go directly panic and sell. You buy on the high, you sell on the low. That’s the biggest mistake that we’re seeing.
Raghda Ibraheem: These panic sell-offs, as we call them. So now, how does financial education change the way markets behave, the way new investors, or old investors even, behave?
Abdallah Harfoush: Look, when I say financial education, I talk more also about investment education, because financial education gives people a plan to manage their money, to manage a portfolio, let’s say their personal portfolio. But when we go to investment education, this is where real retail investors have to understand how the investor behaves when the investor wants to build his portfolio, when he wants to grow it, when something wrong happened, what he does, when we want to diversify. The investment education for investors is more important than financial education. But financial education is more important if they want to manage how to make more money, how to keep the money aside, how to grow their money.
Raghda Ibraheem: Yeah, that’s a great point, because a lot of people want to start, but they don’t know where to start exactly. So it’s good to have these tips. Now, what should everyone know before buying their first share?
Abdallah Harfoush: They should know the share, the company by itself, because some people listen to an influencer, let’s say, or a recommendation on YouTube, or someone, buy the stock. Did you know about the stock? Did you do your due diligence? The company, what is the company? What’s the perspective and the future? What’s the gearing ratio? The debt, is there a potential growth, or are they planning to grow in other countries? All these affect the stock price, if you are talking only about stocks. So if you do the due diligence, the economy in that country, is it going to crash? If it crashes, even the companies will crash with it. So when you do all these due diligence, then you can go and buy a stock not based on a news or based on someone’s recommendation only.
Raghda Ibraheem: Okay, so not based on a news cycle.
Abdallah Harfoush: No. For long term, no. If they want to get it, buy it and then sell it in two weeks, it’s different. If they want to go.
Raghda Ibraheem: Like now, for example, we’re having the AI boom or the tech boom, though it’s maybe crashing a little bit these days, but we have that and people are going strongly into it.
Abdallah Harfoush: True. But the question now, if they go into it now, and let’s say in the US they have new legislations that forbid the pure development of it. Let’s say you have a crash in the world economy. Even those, they will go down. They will have to decrease in price. They will fall in price even though the company is going up, especially if the economic cycle will push for an economic crash.
Because I still believe that you are on the verge of a big economic crash. And if we go to this economic crash, all the stocks will fall. Whether it’s an AI stock or a food stock or a retail stock or whatever it is. So for me, yes, as a long term, if we believe that AI is going to a higher level, then we can invest for the longer term.
Raghda Ibraheem: Got it. So let me ask you before we end this, what is the EcoLearn Summit that we’re going to have soon? Who is it for as well? And tell us about it.
Abdallah Harfoush: Actually, the summit, it’s the eighth edition that we are doing. It’s a summit that we do every single year. Now we are doing it here in Dubai and online. It’s a hybrid event. Last year it was a big one. And the goal of it is to teach people more about the economy and to learn more about financial and investment education, while giving them all the aspects they need to become better, [unclear: “which means more people”].
Most people say I want to make more money, but they don’t have the right mindset. They don’t have the right communication skills. They don’t have the real financial education. Because if you want to make money, how you can make money and not knowing how to spend this money, how to save this money, how to grow this money. So it gives all the aspects of a person, how to become a better person from inside, that will help this person to take action by giving them also the solution, how they can become wealthier and in the right environment and the right way. The most important part: the right way. How to think, how to search, and how to do their own due diligence so they can make it independently. And we are not teaching people how to become followers. We are teaching students, especially, how to become more independent thinkers and start thinking and analyzing before taking.
Raghda Ibraheem: Steps, and have the knowledge and the tools to do so. Thank you so much, Abdallah.
Abdallah Harfoush: It will be on the 28th of November.
Raghda Ibraheem: Perfect. And yeah, I recommend everyone to join the EcoLearn Summit, of course with you. Thank you so much.
Abdallah Harfoush: Thank you, I appreciate it.