Remy Blaire: Post-midterm volatility and wild swings in the bond market have investors questioning whether the AI rally is running out of steam, especially with so much of the S&P’s gains driven by just a dozen mega cap stocks. Well, this week does bring a massive litmus test for both tech as well as the broader deal market, as Anthropic preps to price its blockbuster IPO at a valuation of around $1.4 trillion. We will have to wait and see. But joining us to break down where to find value outside big tech and what to expect from here in capital markets is James O’Day, head of equities at Citizens Bank. James, great to have you here. Thank you so much for joining me.
James O’Day: Thank you so much for having me, Remy.
Remy Blaire: Well, here we are counting down the weeks until the end of 2026, and what a volatile year it has been for the broader markets.
James O’Day: Big time.
Remy Blaire: Yeah. And when we’re looking at the equity markets versus the bond markets, there is a lot to digest here. So tell us whether you think what we’ve been seeing in the equity markets is actually a buying opportunity.
James O’Day: I do. I absolutely think that, and here’s why. Right. So if you look at this year, we’ve seen some constraints to liquidity positions, and we’re seeing that bring down a little bit of valuation multiples. On top of that, economic growth continues to work incredibly strongly. You have oil sliding a little bit. You’ve got hopefully some rate stabilization here, finally, after a very, very long time. And then you’ve got the AI investment and you’ve got the AI adoption, and it still feels like we’re in the early innings. So to me, the market’s looking for some stability. We saw a little bit of clarity from the midterm elections. As you said, we’ve got a big AI week: Nvidia tomorrow night, Anthropic books close Wednesday, we’ll see the pricing on Thursday. But to me, it’s setting up for, I think, a risk-on 2027 in the stock market.
Remy Blaire: Yeah. And the month of November this year seems to be a long year because, as you mentioned, we started out with the midterms and many of us had been paying attention to that. And little did we know that we’d see this volatility in the big AI name, which is Nvidia. And of course, as you mentioned, we will be getting earnings and the Anthropic IPO. But before we get to that, I do want to get your take on the rate environment, especially where bond yields are right now. And we all know that Fed Chair Kevin Warsh has been speaking in San Francisco, and apparently he is saying that the staff are gaming out contingencies on AI impact. And that’s an area that we’re all watching. But what does all of this mean when it comes to the rate outlook heading into 2027?
James O’Day: That’s a great question. And I think entering this year, everyone thought we’d start to see rates come in. Now, I think you’re starting to see consensus that it’s higher for longer. They’re calling for a couple more hikes. To me again, I think it’s just going to be, can we wrap our head around what’s actually going to happen? Obviously, there’s been lots of curveballs thrown at the market of late. I do think that we will see rates elevated for longer than we anticipated in the beginning of the year. A couple of rate hikes. Hopefully geopolitical tensions will settle down a little bit and we can get rates to come in.
Remy Blaire: And as we were counting down to Nvidia’s earnings as well as the [unclear: “town hall”] taking place in mid-week trade, I understand that the Anthropic IPO is going to be a litmus test. And you’re saying this is the real test for the market. So what does it need to prove?
James O’Day: I just think we need to see the market digesting it, trade okay. Right. There was talk of 2 trillion, and then there was talk of 1 trillion. It’s looking like a trillion [unclear: “4,000,000,000,005”]. It sounds like it’s 6 or 7 times oversubscribed. We’ll see how that goes. But to me, SpaceX was a clearing event earlier in the year. Now we’re seeing it with Anthropic. I think there’s a lot of high-quality companies that would love to draft in behind them if the market digested pretty well, and we’ll have to wait and see until Thursday to see how all of this pans out.
Remy Blaire: And we all know that it’s also a big week for data in terms of retail sales and earnings out from some of the retail stores here in the U.S. And when it comes to growth, the consumer is an important part of the economy. So that is something that we’ll continue to watch. But when it comes to the dealmaking side, I understand that you’re calling this a knife fight. So tell us why.
James O’Day: It does feel like a knife fight to the end of the year here. I would say heading into sort of June, July, the market looked great, and it felt really good in terms of the equity capital markets window sort of being open. We saw that same week, sort of 10-year spikes [unclear: “or on bamboo pull”]. It sort of shut down that IPO window for the last 7 or 8 weeks. You’re seeing a lot of activity, but it’s very vertical-specific at the moment. I think if we can sort of get through this Anthropic IPO, the breadth and pipeline behind it is incredibly healthy, actually the healthiest I’ve seen in about five years. So, fingers crossed.
Remy Blaire: Yeah. And one area we’re all paying attention to is artificial intelligence, not just the technology, but also as an investment theme. And ahead of Citizens’ big conference, which is taking place here in New York on Tuesday, how is AI actually helping banks as well as fintechs out there?
James O’Day: So it’s helping just about everybody. Thank you for, we got the big conference tomorrow. Whether you’re looking at it [unclear: “from my seed”], whether it’s M&A bankers, IPO bankers streamlining some of that, but now you’re actually starting to hear what’s next, right? Financial services space, agentic trading. You have all these things that used to be hypotheticals, and now that wave is coming. And so I think you’re seeing sort of the next generation of companies come through. We know about Robinhood. We know about Coinbase. It’s the eToro and the Wealthfront behind it. It’s going to be very interesting to watch as this, I think that will be the story of 2027 within the retail brokerage space, is sort of this agentic trading and what that does, A, for the consumer, and B, what it’s going to do for the actual broker houses too.
Remy Blaire: And before I let you go, you brought up a lot of key points there and questions we don’t have answers to without a crystal ball. But what can we expect as we head into 2027 when it comes to all these technologies?
James O’Day: It’s tough to answer that, considering you didn’t see [unclear: “Nvidia Trauma and Microsoft Trauma in the ground stop last year”]. But to me, I do think every one of these things gets us a little bit more clarity, a little bit more stabilization. I still think we’re going to be in a risk-on environment. The market’s trying to find its footing right now. 2027, to me, feels like a setup for a little bit broader of a rally, versus we’re seeing it very kind of siloed and focused this year.
Remy Blaire: And finally, before I let you go, we have been paying attention to the market rotation. But given everything that’s transpired this year, what do you think is important for investors out there, who are retail traders, to keep in mind?
James O’Day: I think keep an eye on the rates, keep an eye on the consumer. The consumer is starting to feel a little stretched. I’m sure you and I are feeling it day to day as well. But as long as you continue to see earnings growth, we see some type of rate stabilization, to me, I think we’ll see multiple expansion heading into next year, because you’ve actually seen it contract pretty dramatically this year. So to me, valuations look reasonable, set up to have a pretty good run heading into next year.
Remy Blaire: So when it comes to the leaders as well as laggards, do you expect more of the same, or do you expect to see a shift?
James O’Day: I think we’ll see a little bit of a shift. I think it needs to get broader in terms of the rally with the markets. I think you need to see small and mid-cap also come along for the ride, and, you know, vertical by vertical, right? Homebuilders have sort of been left for dead here. Hopefully they get a rebalance to come back. There were 2 or 3 M&A headlines on the tape this morning. And life sciences [unclear: “get that”] to continue to kind of move higher. So I think we’re starting to see signs of it. But it needs to be broader.
Remy Blaire: A lot to keep in mind. And as you mentioned, we did get those M&A announcements. So it did look like an M&A Monday, despite all the other headlines competing for our attention. So thank you so much for joining us today. Appreciate your time.
James O’Day: Appreciate you.