Bassel Sabri: So development banks are still backing Egypt’s solar and battery buildout. In recent days, the EBRD financed a new solar and storage plant in Benban, and the African Development Bank signed on to the plant that will power EGX-listed Egypt Aluminum. But much of that money is still spent in dollars on imported panels and batteries. So what would it take for equipment made in Egypt to win a place in these projects? Joining me right now is Dr. Mahmoud Badran, CTO of Mada Labs. And of course, his background is in materials science and solar cell research. Thank you for joining us, Dr. Mahmoud.
Dr. Mahmoud Badran: Yeah. Thank you for having me.
Bassel Sabri: So your early research in Egypt looked at solar cells made from plant materials. Looking back, what did it teach you about the distance between a promising lab result and something a power plant would actually buy?
Dr. Mahmoud Badran: Yes. That’s really what we call the gap between academia and industry, where in academia you can have a very promising result. It can be very efficient, but especially once you roll it out to industry, you want something that’s very stable, that’s very scalable, and that you can rely on for many, many years. So this was the first result that I saw where you can make a very efficient solar cell. And I did, and we have very optimistic lab results. However, when you roll them out in industry, that becomes a big issue. There have been a lot of efforts to try to roll out, for example, plant-based solar cells, but they haven’t been as successful as silicon-based materials.
Bassel Sabri: And we’re talking about solar plants. We’re talking about plants that sell their power under 25-year contracts. So a panel has to perform for a quarter of a century in Upper Egypt’s heat and dust. As a materials scientist, what actually wears out inside a panel over that kind of time?
Dr. Mahmoud Badran: Yeah. So in terms of the silicon itself, they don’t actually wear out. That’s, I think, a misconception. What matters is everything around [unclear: “the soil infrastructure”] around it. So the plastics, the solder, the joints and the glass surface. And especially for hot deserts, I think experts [unclear: “called”] around 1.5% degradation in efficiency year after year. However, that should still be within the range of the 25-year contracts. There are, of course, other problems around UV exposure, around heat. However, I would imagine that, especially as these centers are designed for that environment, they have the appropriate engineering kit, [unclear: “at least a not disease victim”].
Bassel Sabri: So Scatec has told Enterprise AM that it picks battery suppliers project by project, Egyptian or Chinese, as long as they bring proven technology and lenders check track records and warranties. So how does an Egyptian factory with no track record get its first one?
Dr. Mahmoud Badran: Yeah, it’s a bit of a Catch-22. So you want a track record. You back it against the warranty, or someone that is already trusted, and start with a project small enough to take the risk. So it’s sort of at the beginning. It starts with the belief, but then that sort of snowballs into trusting in those institutions. It’s the same thing with chips. So you can essentially start with a qualification, and then a supplier essentially becomes trustworthy over time. So I don’t think that’s going to be an issue. It just has to be given time to get there.
Bassel Sabri: And also let’s build on that, because Enterprise AM estimates that roughly 70% of the solar project’s cost here is in dollars, mostly imported panels and cells. Which parts of a solar plant could Egypt realistically make at home first, and which will stay imported for years?
Dr. Mahmoud Badran: Yeah, so that’s a very good question. I think in theory you can have everything, but of course you start off with something that’s easy, feasible. So you start off with the heavy stuff like cables, transformers and assembly, that those already exist in Egypt, and you can supply those from local sources. The ones that stay imported tend to be the ones that rely on essentially the center of the supply chain. So wafers and the chips inside inverters. Panels, I don’t think, [unclear: “are make the most of the build”]. Everything else tends to come from the modules and inverters. And a lot of that is going to come from the steel and copper that Egypt already produces. So you can source a lot of, at least, the capital expenditure through local sources. However, in terms of the cells and modules, because you also rely on the supply chains of China, for example, for those. However, the process itself is not that complicated, so over time we might eventually develop a local supply chain for the more advanced solar cells and modules.
Bassel Sabri: Right. And if we zoom in more on what you’re saying here, at the process, we see that the most valuable step in solar, which is turning silicon into ingots and wafers, still sits almost entirely in China. Now, Egypt has the quartz and the white sand. What stands between that sand and a wafer? The technology, the energy bill or the scale? What do you think?
Dr. Mahmoud Badran: I think it’s mostly momentum, actually. So the thing around this is the fact that for silicon ingots, for you to make a wafer from a large ingot, that ingot has to have a very high level of quality. And right now, because of how China has been very competitively building the ingot market, any new entrant has to basically compete with lots of decades of experience. And there is a lot of quality, at least quality control, that has been already established, as well as [unclear: “what I would think of as you basically is not fighting a very winning battle”], also because of the profit margins being really quite squashed. So, sure, it would be very useful to have it in terms of national sovereignty. However, I think in terms of the application layer, that’s something that you can develop a lot of [unclear: “at Delta and Alpha in”].
Bassel Sabri: So in batteries, the cells are most of the value, and the new Scatec-backed plant here will import [unclear: “itself”] from China. What does a real battery cell factory actually need that a pack assembly line does not?
Dr. Mahmoud Badran: Yeah. So this is a very interesting question because, as you mentioned, the most value is right now, it’s not in the [unclear: “solar cells or in the panels on the wafers”]. So [unclear: “a background”] is assembly. It’s just assembly [unclear: “cells”]. A cell factory itself is just basic chemistry. It can’t be done in rooms that are not very dry. And the problem is mostly around yield. So most of the manufacturing lines where you get these cells from have also decades of experience of just understanding the chemistry and how to make sure that they get the best yield. However, right now, let’s say if we start a cell line in Egypt, we will start with very low yields, somewhere in the range of 30%, which is just not going to be very competitive. However, we have started to see developments in this capacity within Egypt, and I would imagine it’s just one of those things that will just take time, as well as, for example, AI helping with producing [unclear: “much better plants”] and newer technologies to develop those cells.
Bassel Sabri: All right. Very quickly, how much time are we looking at, and what kind of progress do you hope for in that domain for Egypt?
Dr. Mahmoud Badran: Yeah. So [unclear: “already came with an aluminum”], already today we have some of the best capabilities that are quite competitive. So solar glass can also come on the way with some of the new developments. But I think one of the unique advantages for Egypt is phosphate, because we have a lot of good phosphate minerals within Egypt, and we can easily scale those as a dark horse, kind of, where we get into a big part of the battery supply chain through the specific parts that are currently being built. I know [unclear: “3D”] is probably one of the frontier companies going for that. But in theory, I see that we don’t have to compete in things that are already well optimized. We can compete on ones that are not as optimized, but we have a very unfair advantage, like also pure phosphoric acid.
Bassel Sabri: Dr. Mahmoud Badran, it’s been a great pleasure to have you with us today on FINTECH.TV. Thank you very much for joining us.
Dr. Mahmoud Badran: Thanks. It’s a pleasure.